{ "schema_version": "r4.1-yishui-core-topology-audit/1.0", "generated_at": "2026-09-28T18:24:16+08:00", "task": "WATER_CLASSIC_R4_1_SCHOLARLY_AUDIT", "section": "R4.1 · Topology simplification (CORE + FULL)", "basis": "R4 frozen commit 582c852 textual_topology_r4.json preserved as FULL_TOPOLOGY; R4.1 adds CORE_TOPOLOGY with claim-to-edge binding", "core_topology_nodes": 9, "core_topology_edges": 15, "full_topology_nodes": 72, "full_topology_edges": 29, "full_topology_preserved": true, "core_node_selection_rationale": { "user_spec_explicit": [ "易水", "故安", "范陽", "容城", "濡水", "巨馬水", "大利亭" ], "evidence_needed_additions": [ "武陽 (R4-YSH-009 燕下都記錄)", "易京 (R4-YSH-011 公孫瓚記錄)" ], "excluded_from_core_but_in_full": [ "金毫陂 (R4-YSH-010 金臺所在陂，非核心地理節點)", "蘭馬臺 (R4-YSH-010 臺名，非獨立核心節點)", "其他65節點 (FULL_TOPOLOGY 詳列)" ] }, "core_nodes": [ { "node_id": "cn_01", "name": "易水", "type": "river", "x": 250, "y": 350, "core_role": "central water body" }, { "node_id": "cn_02", "name": "故安", "type": "historical_place", "x": 100, "y": 250, "core_role": "易水水源" }, { "node_id": "cn_03", "name": "范陽", "type": "historical_place", "x": 400, "y": 350, "core_role": "易水+巨馬水交匯" }, { "node_id": "cn_04", "name": "容城", "type": "historical_place", "x": 500, "y": 350, "core_role": "易水+巨馬水東端" }, { "node_id": "cn_05", "name": "濡水", "type": "river", "x": 250, "y": 150, "core_role": "北側水系" }, { "node_id": "cn_06", "name": "巨馬水", "type": "river", "x": 250, "y": 550, "core_role": "南側水系" }, { "node_id": "cn_07", "name": "大利亭", "type": "historical_place", "x": 350, "y": 500, "core_role": "三水交會地理節點" }, { "node_id": "cn_08", "name": "武陽", "type": "historical_place", "x": 100, "y": 450, "core_role": "燕下都 (R4-YSH-009)" }, { "node_id": "cn_09", "name": "易京", "type": "historical_place", "x": 550, "y": 250, "core_role": "公孫瓚遷都處 (R4-YSH-011)" } ], "core_edges": [ { "edge_id": "ce_001", "subject": "故安", "predicate": "易水出於", "object": "易水", "relation_id": "r_1655_origin_01", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-002", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1655", "exact_excerpt": "易水出涿郡故安縣閻鄉西山", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "svg_x1": 100, "svg_y1": 250, "svg_x2": 250, "svg_y2": 350 }, { "edge_id": "ce_002", "subject": "故安", "predicate": "易水逕城南外東流", "object": "易水", "relation_id": "r_1656_south_city_01", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-003", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1656", "exact_excerpt": "易水逕故安城南外東流", "support_status": "TEXTUAL_INFERENCE", "svg_x1": 100, "svg_y1": 280, "svg_x2": 230, "svg_y2": 340 }, { "edge_id": "ce_003", "subject": "故安", "predicate": "位於濡水之南", "object": "濡水", "relation_id": "r_1659_passes_north_of_01", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-003", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1659", "exact_excerpt": "其水又東南流，歷故安縣北", "support_status": "TEXTUAL_INFERENCE", "svg_x1": 130, "svg_y1": 230, "svg_x2": 240, "svg_y2": 170 }, { "edge_id": "ce_004", "subject": "故安", "predicate": "故安水東南至大利亭", "object": "大利亭", "relation_id": "r_1659_flow_south_01", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-007", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1659", "exact_excerpt": "其水又東南流於容城縣西北大利亭東南", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "svg_x1": 130, "svg_y1": 270, "svg_x2": 340, "svg_y2": 490 }, { "edge_id": "ce_005", "subject": "大利亭", "predicate": "合易水注巨馬水", "object": "巨馬水", "relation_id": "r_1659_meets_01", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-007", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1659", "exact_excerpt": "合易水而注巨馬水也", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "svg_x1": 360, "svg_y1": 510, "svg_x2": 270, "svg_y2": 540 }, { "edge_id": "ce_006", "subject": "易水", "predicate": "逕武陽南", "object": "武陽", "relation_id": "r_1656_passes_south_of_wuyang", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-009", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1656", "exact_excerpt": "易水又東逕武陽南", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "svg_x1": 230, "svg_y1": 360, "svg_x2": 110, "svg_y2": 450 }, { "edge_id": "ce_007", "subject": "武陽", "predicate": "酈道元記為燕下都", "object": "武陽", "relation_id": "r_1656_historical_relation", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-009", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1656", "exact_excerpt": "武陽蓋燕昭王之所城也，東西二十里，南北十七里", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "note": "此 edge 為 self-loop，標示 武陽=燕下都 之 historical_relation", "svg_x1": 100, "svg_y1": 450, "svg_x2": 130, "svg_y2": 480 }, { "edge_id": "ce_008", "subject": "易水", "predicate": "東過范陽縣南", "object": "范陽", "relation_id": "r_1657_passes_south_of_fanyang", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-001", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1657", "exact_excerpt": "東過范陽縣南", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "svg_x1": 270, "svg_y1": 340, "svg_x2": 390, "svg_y2": 350 }, { "edge_id": "ce_009", "subject": "易水", "predicate": "又東過容城縣南", "object": "容城", "relation_id": "r_1657_passes_south_of_rongcheng", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-001", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1657", "exact_excerpt": "又東過容城縣南", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "svg_x1": 410, "svg_y1": 350, "svg_x2": 490, "svg_y2": 350 }, { "edge_id": "ce_010", "subject": "易水", "predicate": "通稱東逕容城縣故城北", "object": "容城", "relation_id": "r_1659_passes_north_of_rongcheng", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-006", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1659", "exact_excerpt": "通稱東逕容城縣故城北", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "svg_x1": 270, "svg_y1": 330, "svg_x2": 490, "svg_y2": 320 }, { "edge_id": "ce_011", "subject": "易水", "predicate": "同入濡水", "object": "濡水", "relation_id": "r_1659_confluences_with", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-006", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1659", "exact_excerpt": "然二易俱出一鄉，同入濡水", "support_status": "TEXTUAL_INFERENCE", "svg_x1": 250, "svg_y1": 320, "svg_x2": 250, "svg_y2": 200 }, { "edge_id": "ce_012", "subject": "易水", "predicate": "東逕易京南", "object": "易京", "relation_id": "r_1661_passes_south_of_yijing", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-011", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1661", "exact_excerpt": "易水又東逕易京南", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "note": "僅 '易水之南' 部分為 TEXT_REPORTS；'範陽以東、容城以西' 為 TEXTUAL_INFERENCE（見 R4-YSH-011 claim）", "svg_x1": 280, "svg_y1": 340, "svg_x2": 540, "svg_y2": 260 }, { "edge_id": "ce_013", "subject": "巨馬水", "predicate": "東南逕范陽縣故城北", "object": "范陽", "relation_id": "r_1682_passes_north_of_fanyang", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-004", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1682", "exact_excerpt": "又東南逕范陽縣故城北，易水注之", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "note": "巨馬水章（pid1682），與易水章不同水系；R4-YSH-004 已標註此水系差異", "svg_x1": 250, "svg_y1": 530, "svg_x2": 390, "svg_y2": 380 }, { "edge_id": "ce_014", "subject": "易水", "predicate": "注於巨馬水", "object": "巨馬水", "relation_id": "r_1682_flows_into_juma", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-006", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1682", "exact_excerpt": "又東南逕范陽縣故城北，易水注之", "support_status": "TEXTUAL_INFERENCE", "svg_x1": 260, "svg_y1": 380, "svg_x2": 250, "svg_y2": 520 }, { "edge_id": "ce_015", "subject": "巨馬水", "predicate": "又東南過容城縣北", "object": "容城", "relation_id": "r_1682_passes_north_of_rongcheng_juma", "claim_id": "R4-YSH-004", "canonical_citation": "SHUGE:p124575:1682", "exact_excerpt": "又東南過容城縣北", "support_status": "TEXT_REPORTS", "svg_x1": 280, "svg_y1": 540, "svg_x2": 490, "svg_y2": 380 } ], "full_topology_source": "data/yishui_textual_topology_r4.json (582c852) — 72 nodes / 29 edges, unchanged in R4.1", "layout_improvement": { "R4_issue": "原 R4 SVG 大量節點使用相同 cy=380 座標，與頁面聲稱的「y軸按 pid1655 → pid1683 排列」不一致，導致節點視覺重疊。", "R4.1_fix": "CORE_TOPOLOGY 採用 9 節點 5 列佈局：(100, 250-450) 故安/武陽；(250, 150-550) 濡水/易水/巨馬水；(350-550, 250-500) 大利亭/范陽/容城/易京。FULL_TOPOLOGY 完整保留於 R4 frozen JSON（不做視覺重排，僅在 /yishui/ 頁面以 fold/appendix 形式呈現）。" }, "hard_boundaries": { "NEW_OCR": 0, "NEW_PRIMARY_ACQUISITION": 0, "DB_WRITES": 0, "EMBEDDINGS": 0, "R4_BASELINE_PRESERVED": true, "FULL_TOPOLOGY_NOT_OVERWRITTEN": true } }