{ "version": "v1.0", "generated_at": "2026-09-28T10:42:30+08:00", "source": "v0.5-v0.9 evidence corpus + v1.0 article outline", "purpose": "Machine-readable consolidated dossier for the v1.0 candidate article. Every claim has at least one citation_id or is marked limitation.", "dossier_id": "dossier-water-classic-digital-life", "article_id_local": "article-water-classic-digital-life-001", "publication_status": "REVIEW", "auto_publish_forbidden": true, "review_status_required_for_publish": "explicit user approval", "title_zh": "《从〈水经注〉到数字证据：一部古籍的数字生命史》", "title_en": "From Shuijing Zhu to Digital Evidence: A Digital Life History of a Classical Text", "short_title_zh": "水经注 · 数字生命史", "short_title_en": "Shuijing Zhu · A Digital Life History", "version_label": "v1.0 Candidate", "linked_draft_id": "draft-hydrology-river-distribution", "linked_project_id": "rp-hydrology-river-distribution", "linked_workspace_id": "ws-hydrology-river-distribution", "linked_research_question_ids": [ "rq-ws1-001", "rq-ws1-002" ], "linked_field_note_ids": [ "FN-20260928-001", "FN-20260928-004" ], "linked_place_ids": [ "sangganhe", "grand_canal" ], "linked_water_classic_work_id": "p124575", "linked_water_classic_pages_count": 60, "citation_ids_used": [ "SHUGE:p168491:68", "SHUGE:p211203:1096", "SHUGE:p211203:1178", "SHUGE:p211203:1320", "SHUGE:p211203:1338", "SHUGE:p44159:552" ], "work_ids_used": [ "work-shuge-168491", "work-shuge-211203", "work-shuge-44159" ], "institution_roles": { "inst-shuge": { "role_in_v1_0_article": "source_platform", "NOT": "publisher", "correction_of_v0_7": "v0.7 bibliography.json typed inst-shuge as 'publisher'; v1.0 article treats it as digital-photograph source platform only. v0.7 file is preserved unmodified.", "audit_recorded_in": "data/institution_roles_v1.0.json" }, "inst-ndl-implicit": { "role_in_v1_0_article": "original_holder", "what_it_provides": "actual scanned volumes that shuge.org photographs from (visible in text_preview: '国立公文書館', 'Natio', '内阁文库')" }, "inst-original-implicit": { "role_in_v1_0_article": "original_creator", "what_it_provides": "historical authorship (郦道元 / 宋应星 / Qing 工部). Pre-modern works frequently have unknown or anonymous publishers." } }, "sections": [ { "section_id": "sec-1-intro", "heading_zh": "引言：从一部古籍说起", "order": 1, "word_target": 150, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "cl-1.1", "text": "本研究关注一部 Northern Wei 时期 (6th c.) 的综合性地理著作传统 (在 v0.7 bibliography 中以 post_id 168491 为标识);原始作者归属 (郦道元) 与具体书名 (《水经注》) 来自外部史学共识,不在本证据集范围内。", "citations": [ "SHUGE:p168491:68" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "limitation": "Original authorship attribution (郦道元) is from external scholarly consensus, NOT from shuge.org or our evidence corpus. [Limitation: classical authorship attribution]", "original_text_in_article": "《水经注》是北魏 (Northern Wei, 6th c.) 郦道元所撰的综合性地理著作.", "narrowed_in_audit": "audit-claim-support-v1.0", "post_narrowing_support_status": "SUPPORTED_with_limitation" } ] }, { "section_id": "sec-2-physical-life", "heading_zh": "《水经注》的物质生命：从竹简到扫描", "order": 2, "word_target": 250, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "cl-2.1", "text": "本证据集并不直接提供 Northern Wei hydrological work profile 的完整物质生命谱系;具体的物理形态链条 (竹简 → 抄本 → 刊刻 → 影印 → 数字化扫描) 不在本证据集范围内,属综述性陈述。", "citations": [ "SHUGE:p211203:1096" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "limitation": "The specific physical-history chain (竹简 → 抄本 → 刊刻 → 影印 → 扫描) is NOT in the evidence corpus. [Limitation: physical-history chain not in evidence corpus]", "original_text_in_article": "《水经注》的早期物质形态包括抄本,后经历多次刊刻,20 世纪以来出现影印本与数字化扫描.", "narrowed_in_audit": "audit-claim-support-v1.0", "post_narrowing_support_status": "METADATA_ONLY_research_gap" } ] }, { "section_id": "sec-3-rivers", "heading_zh": "文献中的河流：从经注到现代水系", "order": 3, "word_target": 400, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "cl-3.1", "text": "Northern Wei 时期综合性地理著作传统 (本证据集中以 post_id 168491 为代表) 涉及的地理范围被认为覆盖了当时主要河流体系;具体的河流数量统计 (例如「137/1252」) 不在本证据集范围内。", "citations": [ "SHUGE:p168491:68", "SHUGE:p211203:1096", "SHUGE:p211203:1178" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "limitation": "The exact count (137/1252) is NOT in evidence corpus. [Limitation: numerical claims unverified by citations]", "original_text_in_article": "《水经注》记载了主要河流与支流,覆盖今天中国大部分主要水系 (河水/江水 等).", "narrowed_in_audit": "audit-claim-support-v1.0", "post_narrowing_support_status": "SUPPORTED_with_limitation" }, { "claim_id": "cl-3.2", "text": "古今水系名称的等同关系 (例如「河水」≈ 黄河、「江水」≈ 长江) 来自外部史学共识,不在本证据集范围内;本文不作考证性论断。", "citations": [ "SHUGE:p211203:1178", "SHUGE:p211203:1320", "SHUGE:p211203:1338" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "limitation": "The specific equivalence (河水=黄河) is NOT in evidence corpus. [Limitation: name-equivalence mapping not in evidence corpus]", "original_text_in_article": "《水经注》记载的河流名称与现代水系名称存在音近/同源关系 (河水=黄河, 江水=长江).", "narrowed_in_audit": "audit-claim-support-v1.0", "post_narrowing_support_status": "METADATA_ONLY_research_gap" } ] }, { "section_id": "sec-4-field-observation", "heading_zh": "实地观测：桑干河与运河", "order": 4, "word_target": 350, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "cl-4.1", "text": "桑干河 (永定河上游) 在 2026-09-15 的一次实地观测中,河床呈干涸状态;该观察记录在 field_note FN-20260928-001 中 (verification_status=NEEDS_REVIEW)。这一观察与 Northern Wei 时期 hydrological work profile 中描述的水文状态之间的具体关系,不在本证据集直接验证范围内。", "citations": [ "FN-20260928-001", "SHUGE:p124575:1" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "field_note_id": "FN-20260928-001", "limitation": "Field observation by anonymized fieldworker-A; NOT an independent ground-truth. [Limitation: single-observer field note]", "reliability": "MEDIUM", "original_text_in_article": "桑干河 (永定河上游) 在 2026-09 实地观测时河床已干涸,与《水经注》记载之'水势浩荡'明显不符.", "narrowed_in_audit": "audit-claim-support-v1.0", "post_narrowing_support_status": "SUPPORTED_obs_plus_LIMITATION_compared" }, { "claim_id": "cl-4.2", "text": "京杭大运河通州段在 2026-09-25 的一次实地观测中被记录为可通航状态 (FN-20260928-004, verification_status=UNVERIFIED);该观察与古代「漕运」水道之间的延续性判断不在本证据集直接验证范围内 (SHUGE:p48341:50 OCR QUEUED, not CHECKED)。", "citations": [ "FN-20260928-004", "SHUGE:p48341:50" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "field_note_id": "FN-20260928-004", "limitation": "Single observation; specific 河防一览 page 50 OCR is QUEUED, not CHECKED. [Limitation: navigation status not independently verified]", "reliability": "LOW", "original_text_in_article": "京杭大运河通州段 2026-09 仍可通航,与《水经注》记载之'漕运'水道基本延续.", "narrowed_in_audit": "audit-claim-support-v1.0", "post_narrowing_support_status": "SUPPORTED_obs_plus_LIMITATION_compared" } ] }, { "section_id": "sec-5-discussion", "heading_zh": "与既有研究的位置", "order": 5, "word_target": 250, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "cl-5.1", "text": "现有数字人文 (DH) 研究中,对 《水经注》的处理多以文本检索、GIS 标注为主;以「数字生命史」为元视角的研究尚属空白.", "citations": [ "SHUGE:p211203:1320", "SHUGE:p211203:1338" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "limitation": "The 'DH research gap' claim is an observation by the article author, not a citation. [Limitation: DH literature-review claim not directly cited]" } ] }, { "section_id": "sec-6-limitations", "heading_zh": "方法局限", "order": 6, "word_target": 200, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "cl-6.1", "text": "本研究方法受限于书格 OCR 队列未完成 QA、字段文献未独立获取、田野观测样本量小等.", "citations": [ "SHUGE:p44159:552" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "limitation": "This is a methodological limitation claim, not a factual claim about any specific river. [Limitation: methodological; not a factual assertion]", "reliability": "UNVERIFIED for method-level claims" } ] }, { "section_id": "sec-7-ethics", "heading_zh": "数字证据的伦理与边界", "order": 7, "word_target": 300, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "cl-7.1", "text": "数字证据的「证据性」与古籍本身的「文本性」存在错位;前者是 hosted scan + OCR + ID,后者是 manuscript + commentary + reader.", "citations": [ "SHUGE:p168491:68", "SHUGE:p211203:1320", "SHUGE:p211203:1338" ], "evidence_card_ids": [], "limitation": "This is a conceptual / methodological reflection, not a factual claim about any specific river. [Limitation: conceptual reflection; not an empirical claim]" } ] }, { "section_id": "sec-8-closing", "heading_zh": "结语 / 待续", "order": 8, "word_target": 150, "claims": [ { "claim_id": "cl-8.1", "text": "本文当前状态: REVIEW (DRAFT → REVIEW 自动;非 PUBLISHED).", "citations": [], "evidence_card_ids": [], "limitation": "Status statement, not a citation-requiring claim. [Status: REVIEW — awaiting explicit user approval for PUBLISHED]" } ] } ], "audit": { "total_sections": 8, "total_claims": 10, "total_unique_citations_used": 6, "total_unique_field_notes_used": 2, "total_unique_research_questions_used": 2, "all_claims_have_citation_or_limitation": true, "all_citation_ids_preserved_verbatim_from_v0_7": true, "shuge_referenced_as_source_platform_not_publisher": true, "no_auto_publish": true, "no_new_resources_downloaded": true, "no_ocr_run": true, "no_embeddings_introduced": true, "provenance_files_unchanged": true, "peer_review_label_simulated_workflow": true }, "stats": { "total_citations": 6, "total_works": 3, "total_field_notes_used": 2, "total_research_questions_used": 2, "total_evidence_paragraphs_reused": 9, "total_claims_with_citation_or_limitation": 10, "total_limitations_marked": 10, "word_target_total": 2050, "article_local_id": "article-water-classic-digital-life-001", "dossier_local_id": "dossier-water-classic-digital-life" }, "boundary_compliance": { "no_new_download": true, "no_db_modification": true, "no_ocr_run": true, "citation_id_unchanged": true, "no_auto_publish": true, "no_embeddings": true, "no_auto_generate_historical_facts": true, "shuge_source_platform_not_publisher": true, "peer_review_simulated_workflow_labeled": true, "provenance_unchanged": true }, "v0_files_preserved_unchanged": [ "data/bibliography.json", "data/research_drafts.json", "data/research_articles.json", "data/research_questions.json", "data/field_notes.json", "data/evidence_paragraphs.json", "data/evidence_cards_v3.json", "data/water_classic_pages.json", "data/citations.json", "data/places.json", "data/research_workspaces.json", "data/research_projects.json", "data/collections.json", "data/architecture_pages.json", "data/hydrology_pages.json" ], "v1_0_files_new": [ "data/institution_roles_v1.0.json", "data/article_water_classic_dossier.json", "PUBLICATION_PLAN.md", "EVIDENCE_DOSSIER.md", "ARTICLE_OUTLINE.md", "publications/water-classic-digital-life/index.html", "publications/water-classic-digital-life/evidence/index.html", "methods/citation-bound-historical-research/index.html" ], "narrowing_audit_id": "audit-claim-support-v1.0", "narrowing_audit_path": "data/claim_support_audit_v1.0.json", "narrowing_audit_md_path": "CLAIM_SUPPORT_AUDIT.md", "narrowed_at": "2026-09-28T10:58:00+08:00", "NOT_SUPPORTED_remaining_in_article": 0 }